In these times of bad news–whether on a personal or world-wide level–seemingly becoming the norm, an online arrival of praise can be a pleasant, even shocking, surprise. Such as an email I opened the other day:
Dear J.P.,
I hope you’re having a great week. My name is John Scognamiglio, and I’m Editor-in-Chief at Kensington Publishing Corp. With over 25 years of experience acquiring and editing commercial fiction, I acquire across a broad range of categories, including historical fiction, literary fiction, and family sagas.
I recently came across your work, particularly Cinders Over the Junction, and was deeply moved by the sweeping, intimate Irish-American family chronicle you’ve crafted. The way you trace a family’s journey from the devastating mid-19th century Irish Potato Famine through the explosive, soot-stained rise of the American railway boom, all the way to the paradigm-shifting event of September 11, 2001, is a masterclass in multi-generational storytelling. The junction itself becomes a central character, acting as a mirror for the physical and mental cinders raining down on working-class families caught in the gears of the Second Industrial Revolution. The fact that readers and critics celebrate this as your absolute masterwork, setting the grand stage for your historical legacy, speaks volumes about the quality of your storytelling. It’s always exciting to discover writing that feels both engaging and assured.
I was also captivated by your ability to maintain deep character introspection and blue-collar authenticity across your catalog. From Beyond the Divide, which dives into the Second Industrial Revolution and labor movements, to I’ll Take You Home Kathleen and the sharp contemporary pivot of Joel Emmanuel, you demonstrate a remarkable talent for capturing the foundational roots of the American labor movement and the lives of working-class families across monumental economic changes. Your minimalist lifestyle in a remote Pacific Northwest cabin near Bellingham Bay clearly infuses your prose with a deliberate, focused attention on human elementals, free from digital noise.
Subject to reviewing further material, I believe there could be scope for a broader discussion regarding potential fit within our Kensington Books historical fiction and literary fiction programs. Kensington has an open submission policy and is happy to work with unagented, hybrid, or indie authors. Given the critical acclaim for Cinders Over the Junction, your unique ability to blend psychological depth with societal historical fiction, and your proven track record of crafting voice-driven immigrant sagas, I can see your work resonating strongly with our readers. I’m also personally invested in building authors’ careers and understand the value of a long-term partnership.
I’d love to learn more about your current and forthcoming projects, as well as whether you are represented by a literary agent. If you do have representation, I’d be very happy to continue any conversation via your agent. If not, I’d be glad to outline how the process works at Kensington Publishing should there be mutual interest.
If this sounds of interest, I would be delighted to hear from you. Please feel free to reply directly to this email, and we can arrange a time to discuss your projects in greater detail.
I look forward to the possibility of working together.
(Note from J.P. Kenna: Since publishing my blog post last week, I learned that there is a real John Scognamiglio, who is in fact a respected literary agent and publisher, affiliated with a reputable publisher, Kensington Books–aka Kensington Publishing Corp. My comments to “John S.” are addressed to the actual sender of the fraudulent email. My apologies to John Scognamiglio and Kennsington Books, who are likewise victims of the fraud being perpetrated by AI-assisted scammers targeting authors.)
I thank the sender of the above missive, Mr. John S., Editor-in Chief at Kensington Publishing Corp., for the effusive praise. I’ve had agents and editors praise my work before, but, with stacks of submissions (in the trade unflatteringly known as the “slush pile”) to wade through, they tend to be brief and to the point. But then, this was no courteous opening to a routine rejection–though as an acceptance, it was vague and roundabout. As were his descriptions of my works. And so I feel compelled to pose a few questions to Mr. John S. For a start, John , have you actually done any real reading of my books or manuscripts? Of even one?
Surly, you could not be a fake and make up such a last name as Scognamiglio! Though as Editor-in-Chief, you surely wouldn’t botch the name of your company. Yet in looking up “Kensington Publishing Corp,” I landed on the website of Kensington Books, a reputable family-owned publisher in business since 1974. Allow me to apologize for my overly suspicious nature, John. To even insinuate that you were faking at being a representative of Kensington Books! And fouling up the name in the process. By the way, my looking up Kensington Books did lead to a post warning of a scam, whereby it seems ignoble miscreants (such as yourself?) are sending messages to authors, in order to mislead them into sending money and/or banking information to your possibly bogus entity, Kensington Publishing Corp.! The legitimate Kensington Books states they do not ask for money or banking information upfront. Again, forgive me, John, but might you be nothing more than a loathsome sort of petty criminal that has been around for ages?
The dregs of humanity long known as confidence men and snake-oil peddlers at least operated openly, showing their faces to the people they were bilking and swindling. You modern-day parasites hide behind digital curtains, employing AI to do your dirty work, keeping your pudgy hands clean and uncalloused. Yet when it comes to honest living, the rats scurrying and feeding below the outhouse seat are a lifeform superior to yours,
And, by the way, John, I see where your AI feelers and mandibles have led you to my website, wherein I describe and share a few photos of a cabin on Bellingham Bay I was caretaker of for a time. And so your feelers have led your AI minions to bray about my “minimalist lifestyle in a remote Pacific Northwest cabin.” And that, as your robot hack writer intones, clearly infuses my prose “with a deliberate, focused attention on human elements, free from digital noise.” The irony is unmistakable, though it may be unnoticed by the likes of yourself, John, as I really do not know even who you are, let alone what you are. Are you human with machine-like traits or machine with human-like traits?
A final irony: that the most comprehensive praise in a single message I’ve yet received for my writings has come from an AI generated scam. But then, having been in this world for over 80 years, and though finding it increasingly strange, I still hang on to a thread of optimism. And hoefully, to a sense of humor (even in regards to a situation not at all funny). As such, why whine like a victim, when I might turn it into an upside-down promotion? To benefit me and those from whom I’ve benefitted.
To wit: Award-winning novel Joel Emmanuel is available at Seaport Books in La Conner, Washington. The friendly, well-stocked store on the waterfront in the heart of the historic town north of Seattle is in itself worth a visit. Or order from seaportbooks.com, and check out the rest of their select offerings.
Or if you were as taken as I was with the purple prose of Mr. John S’s scamming AI prose and would actually like to read Cinders Over the Junction, email me at ssmpc45jpk@comcast.net and I can get a copy to you. But please–no scammers! And no Artificial Intelligence-generated missives!
And by the way, fellow author Dante has a special overheated place for you scammers preying on struggling writers–and on the elderly (I happen to be both). And an even more infernal setting for those of you employing AI for your abominable misdeeds.
Recently I read a post from Patricia Marshall of Luminare Press, a reputable hybrid publisher based in Eugene, Oregon, warning of scammers posing as agents or editors, sending AI generated messages to authors for nefarious purposes. Among the red flags to be on the lookout for were overly long messages, excessively flowery language and praise, and unspecific references to plot and subject matter. Over the past year such operators have used new AI technology to collect reams of data available from reviews, back-cover blurbs, and plot summaries to feign interest in the targeted authors work, without ever having to actually read the content. The site put out by Luminare Press on how to spot scams aimed at writers should be a requirement for anyone involved in writing and/or publishing. Thank you, Patricia!
A final note: It seems like navigating WordPress to create a blog has gotten more complicated of late. Or perhaps my brain is just getting simpler.
Heading photo–Kenna as engineer on Tugboat Janet W. at Salmon Bay, Seattle. 1975
Most recent photo, taken by good friend White Miller, at Lake Padden, Bellingham, WA. April 2026

























